Public Records

Your PDF redactions may not be permanent. Here is how to check.

By el • November 17, 2026 • 14 views
In most PDF tools a black box is a shape drawn on top of the page. The text underneath is still in the file, and anyone who receives it can often copy it straight out. Here is a two-minute test you can run on a record you have already released.

Open a public records response your office released in the last year. Find a page with a black box over a name, an address or an account number. Click just to the left of the box, hold the mouse down, drag across it, and press copy. Then paste into anything that takes text.

If the redacted words appear in the paste, they were never removed. They were covered.

Why this happens

A PDF is not a picture of a page. It is a set of instructions: draw this text at this position in this font, draw this image here, draw this rectangle there. The text and the rectangle are separate objects that know nothing about each other.

When someone uses a drawing tool, a highlighter set to black, or a shape annotation to cover sensitive information, the editor adds one more instruction to the end of the list: draw a black rectangle at these coordinates. Every earlier instruction is untouched. On screen the result looks final, because the rectangle is drawn last and sits on top. Underneath it, the original text is exactly where it always was, selectable and searchable.

This is not a bug, and the tools are not misbehaving. A drawing tool is doing precisely what it says it does. The problem is that the result looks identical to a real redaction, and nothing in the interface tells you otherwise.

Three ways to check

Run these on a copy, not on your only version of the file.

Select and copy. Drag across the redacted area and paste the result somewhere. This catches the most common case in a few seconds.

Search the document. If you know what was redacted - a surname, a street, a case number - use the reader's find function and search for it. A match inside a blacked-out area means the text is still indexed in the file.

Open it somewhere else. Try the file in a different PDF reader, a web browser, or a text extraction tool. Annotations are handled differently from one application to the next, and a box that renders opaque in one can render semi-transparent, move, or disappear entirely in another.

There is a fourth case worth knowing about even though it is harder to test for. A document can carry information that never appears on any page: the author and revision history in its metadata, earlier versions kept for undo, comments, and attached files. A scanned document that has been through optical character recognition also carries a text layer sitting invisibly behind the image, and that layer is not covered by anything drawn on top of it.

The same test is question one of a free five-question worksheet covering the rest of the process: whether you could reconstruct an old request, where records actually live, what is published, and who covers when the usual person is away. An afternoon's work and no obligation.

If the test fails

First, do not re-release the same file with a better box on it. If the underlying text is in the document, the only reliable fix is to produce the response again from the original, using a method that removes content rather than covering it.

Second, find out how far it goes. One file redacted this way usually means a method, not a mistake - whoever produced it was probably trained that way, and will have produced others. The question to answer is which releases used the same process, not whether this one file was unlucky.

Third, treat it as a process question rather than an individual one. In every office we have looked at, this was done carefully by someone who believed the information was gone. The interface gave them no reason to think otherwise.

What proper redaction requires

Real redaction deletes the underlying content and leaves the mark in its place. Several mainstream PDF applications include a genuine redaction function, usually separate from the drawing tools and typically involving two steps: mark the areas, then apply, at which point the content is removed and the file is rewritten.

Three things are worth insisting on whatever tool you use:

  • The underlying text and image content in the marked area is removed from the file, not covered.
  • Metadata, comments, attachments and any invisible text layer from scanning are handled too, not just the visible page.
  • Someone checks the result afterwards rather than trusting that it worked, because a redaction that silently fails looks exactly like one that worked.

That last point is the one most often skipped. Verification is not a formality. It is the only part of the process that can tell you the difference between a correct release and a disclosure.

Why this matters more in Florida

Florida's public records law is among the broadest in the country. Records are requested frequently, by anyone, for any reason, and once a file leaves your office you cannot take it back. A response that still contains exempt information underneath a black box has been disclosed, whatever the screen showed when it was sent.

That asymmetry is why we check this first on every engagement. Most compliance findings describe a risk. This one describes something that may have already happened, and the only way to know is to look.

We are a technology consultancy, not a law firm. This article is about how files and tools behave, not about your obligations. If a test like the one above turns something up, your city attorney or district counsel is the right next call, not us.

If you want someone to look properly

Redaction is one part of our public records and Sunshine compliance assessment: a three-week, fixed-price review of how requests actually move through your agency, where the gaps are, and what to fix first. It covers where records live, what is retained, how requests are tracked against their deadlines, and whether what you release is what you intended to release.

You do not need us to run the test at the top of this article, though. Do that today either way.

Ready to Transform Your Business?

Schedule a free consultation with our experts and discover how we can help you achieve your goals.

  • Personalized strategy session
  • Expert insights and recommendations
  • No obligation, free consultation